
Edson Fachin, chief justice of Brazil’s Federal Supreme Court (STF), is awaiting the return of Justice Flávio Dino’s request to review a case before resuming proceedings involving justices Alexandre de Moraes and André Mendonça, both tied to investigations into Banco Master.
Vote was tied before the suspension
The impasse began at the plenary session of September 15, when justices considered a procedural motion from Gilmar Mendes proposing that the proceedings tied to Moraes and Mendonça be merged into a single judgment. Gilmar, Dino, Cristiano Zanin and Moraes himself voted to merge the petitions; Fachin, Mendonça, Luiz Fux and Cármen Lúcia voted to keep the proceedings separate.
With the vote provisionally tied, Dino requested more time to review the case, suspending the vote before a conclusion was reached. Under STF rules, a justice has up to 90 days to return the case file — otherwise it is automatically released for the judgment to continue. Since the request was made on September 15, the deadline runs to December.
Review request also pulled a hearing from the docket
The impasse led Fachin to pull the hearing on Mendonça’s conduct, originally scheduled for Wednesday (23), from the docket. That proceeding concerns an accusation by Moraes that Mendonça improperly handled cases tied to Banco Master and the INSS social security fraud probe — and Dino’s request for more time aims precisely to bring the analysis of both cases together.
Until the full court resolves the procedural question, it remains unclear whether the two cases will be examined jointly or separately. Justices and the Attorney General’s Office have already given Fachin their input on the matter.
Update (Sept 27): Dino weighs returning the case only after the runoff
According to Folha de S.Paulo, allies of Justice Flávio Dino say he is weighing releasing the judgment on the Federal Police report — containing messages attributed to former banker Daniel Vorcaro with references to Alexandre de Moraes (Petition 16,662, based on data extracted from Vorcaro’s phone) — only after the second round of the elections. Dino reportedly told associates and fellow justices that it would make no sense to resume the discussion right before the vote, given the risk that the court’s crisis could affect the outcome.
The merits of the petition tied to Moraes were not examined by the full court at the September 15 session. Dino has until December to return the case, though he may do so earlier. According to the same report, the group close to Moraes sees an electoral risk and is trying to cool the crisis. For now, this is an assessment relayed by allies: there is no formal decision from the justice on when he will return the case file.


Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.